You are here

WWDC 2014 and the future of Aperture, iPhoto and Photos

PhotoJoseph's picture
June 2, 2014 - 10:17pm

The WWDC 2014 keynote is over (watch it here), and there were several references to the world of photography, but unfortunately nothing about Aperture directly (or iPhoto, for what that's worth). If you want to watch the photos section, skip to 73:25 to get started. And if you want to see the comments already made on the live-blog of the keynote, head here.

So, what did we learn?

“Every photo you take. On all your devices.”

The major takeaway was that through Mac OS X Yosemite and iOS 8, we will see a new iCloud photo storage feature, allowing us to access and edit far more photos than we can see on a single iOS device today—up to 1TB of them. You can see the pricing tiers (at least up to 200GB) in the screenshot below.

Up to 1TB cloud photo storage available

1TB is a lot of storage, but it's not enough for everyone. I have around 3.5 or 4TB of data between my Aperture library and all the originals. How excessive data will be handled wasn't mentioned, although one presumes that you could just pay for what storage you wanted, and somehow tag projects or time spans that should be available in iCloud. 

The editing controls shown were not only non-destructive, and syncing via iCloud, but also much more advanced than anything we've seen in iOS before. The basic “Light” slider is actually made up of brightness, contrast, exposure, highlights and shadows—adjustments we all know and love, here controlled intelligently with a single “Light” slider, and also accessible individually. It's admittedly very nice.

These adjustments are far more advanced than what we’re used to in iOS

Other than a cool search demo, and showing an image crop synchronizing from an iPad to an iPhone, there wasn't much else on display. 

We saw photo adjustments synchronized between an iPad and iPhone via iCloud

Then finally, the only real mention of what's coming in the future was this reference…

“We are working on a new grounds-up photo solution for the Mac built with iCloud in mind” […] “…shipping early next year”

That sentence sums up what we now know about the future of photo apps on the Mac. The demo that proceeded that statement didn't look  like an iPhoto or Aperture app, but basically just a clone of the iOS Photos app, running on OS X. Maybe that's the future of iPhoto, although I'm sure things like cards and calendars and books will still be there. I believe what we saw running on OS X Yosemite today was just a technology demo, simply to show iCloud syncing, and not any indicator of what iPhoto or Aperture will look like.

EDIT: Maybe not; I missed this screenshot before. This makes it look much more robust, so perhaps this is the future of iPhoto/Aperture:

Is this the future of iPhoto and Aperture?

There's no place for Photos and iPhoto on OS X (or iOS for that matter, if you're going to put this much capability into Photos), so either Photos is the new iPhoto, or it'll be rebranded before launch. 

We also saw what looks to be a very nice new plug-in type architecture for iOS called “Extensibility” where developers can make their app accessible from the Photos app. The screenshot below from a demo that starts around 88:25 shows a “photo filter” accessing the apps VSCOCam and Waterlogue. 

Accessing third-party apps from within the Photos app on iOS is a very nice development

There are two huge questions here though that weren't addressed. First, is this non-destrucive? If so, like with the built-in adjustments, we could presumably open that photo and re-edit it later. That seems logical since there was no save or export step in the demo, and there's no way Apple would just overwrite your original photo. There could be a “revert” feature, but hopefully the adjustments are stored non-destrucively, and can be re-edited later on, on this or another device. And the second point is OS X functionality. If this “Extensibility” is, er, extended to OS X, then we're talking about a whole new plug-in architecture for the future photo app ecosystem.

2015

So what about that date? “Early next year” is 2015. Are we going to see a new Aperture before then, giving us the features we've been gagging for for years now? Will we see an iPhoto and iPhoto Pro type of workflow? What about our existing libraries; you can't make a future version of Aperture that just throws away the last decade of work (Aperture 1.0 was released in 2005), so even if the simplified iOS-type workflow is the future, our existing photos can't be left behind.

Level:
Beginner
App:
Apple Aperture Apple Photos for iOS Apple Photos for macOS
Platform:
macOS iOS
Author:
PhotoJoseph

I would like to see a “Photos” app which combines current iPhoto simplicity and Aperture functionalities pro. Like a new iMovie which combines Final Cut Pro X and current iMovie.

Another way would be to have “Photos” replacing iPhoto, and an update for Aperture with Yosemite interface. Because current Aperture on Yosemite DP1 is very bad… Mavericks interface and 3D icon… Looks very bad for professional OS as make Apple so good.

I know that current pro apps are not free, but with iWork and iLife free now, maybe pro apps will be in next months/years… And combines these apps would be good.

 

Judging the look of Aperture in Yosemite is a tad early… In fact Yosemite is only open to developers and so far I’d recommend anyone not to use Yosemite on a production machine (I’m a developer), it looks very promising but it is not ready for prime time yet, so be careful with your precious images… You never know what could happen.

As to Photos, Aperture and iPhoto, Apple has not yet signaled a merge of its pro and consumer apps. In fact they have clearly updated Final Cut and Logic as Pro apps with a premium, unlike their consumer suite. I may be wrong bug I wouldn’t compare iWorks with the creative apps. I think the move to free iWork apps was to push Microsoft to become active on both the Mac and iOS, with the side effect to benefit users who only need simple office apps which now come for free on their new mac.

With Extensions though this could change, if Apple decides to make the creative apps (movie, music and photo) into ecosystems, they could deploy with Photos a minimalist backbone/feature set and let 3rd party developer enrich the ecosystem with sophisticated premium functionalities via Extensions. Future will tell…

Christian C. Berclaz
www.photoanimalium.com

Yeah, I saw the look of Aperture on Yosemite, I’m too a developer (but I reinstalled Mavericks just after for stability). I’m hoping for a new Aperture with Yosemite interface (flat buttons) and flat icon at least. Because at side of others flat icons on dock, Aperture looks bad with his 3D icon.

I understand your vision. We will see in october more details I hope for Aperture, iPhoto and Photos… Because vision of Apple isn’t very clear about these different apps…  As much as iTunes red icon actually (new iTunes version?… Not available in DP1…)

Personally, I think I prefer to have only one application for photos. As you say, Photos for simplicity, and buy premium extensions for professionals, into a same app. But maybe a professional pack of extensions (for price of current Aperture), rather than buy each extension one by one…

+1 on the look of Aperture and Yosemite! Frankly after getting used to iOS 7, I cannot wait for Yosemite :)

We see where Apple brings us, not sure if it will be already in October (I expect the focus to be on the new iOS hardware and PMA is only in January which, though we could also be surprised earlier at Photokina…)

In any case, if Apple is really after building ecosystems it will have to make them live: thus I wouldn’t expect too much to “just” pay what the current Aperture cost… Same as iPhoto, Photos might be free and, like everyone since the App Store was launched for the iPhone, Photos users will have, after a while, spent many times over what they would have spent for just Aperture… Not necessarily a bad thing though: you can’t get progress without somehow funding it…

Christian C. Berclaz
www.photoanimalium.com

Pages

You may login with either your assigned username or your e-mail address.
Passwords are case-sensitive - Forgot your password?